R 1200 GS (LC) 2017 vs Stelvio 2024

If straight-line speed is your priority, the R 1200 GS (LC) takes the lead. With 10 HP more than the Stelvio, it offers a more spirited ride that will be noticeable on highway overtakes or track days. Both bikes share a similar footprint on the scale, with only a negligible 2kg difference between them, so handling characteristics will depend more on center-of-gravity than raw weight. Riders with a shorter inseam should lean towards the Stelvio. Its seat height is 20mm lower than the R 1200 GS (LC), making it much easier to flat-foot at stoplights and increasing confidence during stops. Bottom Line: It's a close call. Choose the r1200gs if you prefer its specific styling and ergonomics, or the stelvio if you want the alternative brand character.